13 Comments
User's avatar
TBLive's avatar

Or I’d rather fail at the economics by writing what I most want to read than to sell my soul and probably still not make a penny.

Ged's avatar

Thank you, dearly, for your work. It’s tough, I know, but everything but being a massive, disgusting dickhead is getting tougher these days. I appreciate your work and I appreciate your curation and I wanted to stress on this occasion again how important it is.

Literary appreciation - frankly, any sort of literacy - is increasingly becoming a political act. I do not like this and neither should anyone but this is just how things are. There is a dying of the light and that makes it tough. Will probably make it tougher still. So have my gratitude for playing your part in keeping that flame alive.

There‘s tough times ahead. It’s good to have you around.

GeorginaAnneTaylor's avatar

I was told that collections of short stories don't sell and publishers aren't interested. So do I stop writing them? Nope, putting them on Substack instead. I had a literary agent, had a bid on my first novel, ended up going the self publishing route. I removed my work from Amazon last year (don't feed the billionaires). I don't see much of a future publishing-wise, especially not in this climate. I have no social media and I am allergic to self-promotion. So I'm not looking to grow a following here either. Substack beats putting my writing onto memory sticks, which then go into a drawer, never to be read.

S. K. Ratidox's avatar

Great article. I find myself sometimes second-guessing my decision to self-publish and use Substack rather than throwing query letters and sales pitches to the fortress of traditional publishing. It's discouraging when people claim there is only one way to get readers interested in your work. I have been told of countless romance and fantasy and even classical literature that comes high recommended, that I will never read because I have many other stories worth my time. I appreciate someone calling out the hypocrisy of the gatekeepers dismissing platforms like Substack and I appreciate the acknowledgement of the reckless world of only online posting.

Raven Magill's avatar

Oh how I needed to read this. Thank you for Only Poems. And your insight, and knowledge, and enthusiasm. And I'm so excited to see how Strange Pilgrims blooms.

margi cates's avatar

Thank you for this.

I care, I write, I read, I drag strange shapes from the liminal space, I linger on the beach, waiting for tug behind my navel. I can’t do anything else.

Make things, hate them, love them, poke at them, walk the line between hope and despair.

Knit my dreams into lopsided sleeves.

Amelia Colwell's avatar

I needed to read this, thank you for writing it! It reminds me of an Audre Lorde quote I have on a post-it note on my mirror: “I am who I am, doing what I came to do.” 💜

Buzz Kantwrite's avatar

That picture looks like me at a very busy cafe. Only difference is I am constantly loudly clearing my throat and then smiling and nodding at people.

Sometimes I will say, “Have you read this? It’s very good. It’s my second time.”

Richard Ryal's avatar

Yes. Many answers are right, but the best answer is always the one right for you. Specifically you. Shannan’s posts in Beautiful Losers could readily compile into a writer’s support text, titled Reality + for Writers, and she’ll likely surprise us with her photorealistic fantasy romcom about the inhabitants on Myopia 4. But while it’s tough, sure, writing what’s under our skin satisfies in a distinct way no one knows until they dig into a blank page/screen themselves. Just make sure that, like Shannan and Karan, you displace the Conformist Vertebra and forget to call the chiropractor. If you win a prize for it, presume we already know your worth.

Michele Peters's avatar

I have been overwhelmed with the year-in-review and new year goals lately (it's me, not any of you posting those, I promise). But this. THIS is just what I needed to read today. Thank you, Shannan.

Dianne Moritz's avatar

However, I'm happy for those fortunate enough to succeed on this platform.

Dianne Moritz's avatar

I agree with all the comments about Substack here.

When I want to read good literature I go to the library.

I'm a senior citizen living on a paltry ss payout. I can't afford to "upgrade to pay.".

I tried Substack and don't like the concept, so stopped posting.